WTO《SCM协定》中的“同类产品”——以“欧美大型民用飞机贸易措施争端”为例
Interpretation of “Like Products” in SCM Agreement based on the Critical Study of WTO Decisions on Boeing-Airbus Disputes
-
摘要:“同类产品”的界定关系到判断一国补贴措施是否符合WTO《SCM协定》。而《SCM协定》中“同类产品”定义非常抽象和模糊,加上WTO实践对“同类产品”的认定没有统一标准,这不利于WTO成员准确地履行《SCM协定》下的义务。通过分析欧美大型民用飞机贸易争端中WTO争端解决机构对“同类产品”的理解,结合《SCM协定》“同类产品”条款的法理解释,认为:《SCM》协定下“同类产品”的界定首先应满足《SCM协定》注46的规定。其次,在“相关市场中产品之间的竞争关系”是认定《SCM协定》中“同类产品”诸多因素中尤其值得重视、提倡和采用的判断标准。Abstract:The specific coverage of obligations under the SCM Agreements hinges upon the definition and resulting scope of “like products”. While this subject is certainly one of the most fundamental issues in the field of SCM Agreement, its blurring boundary has not been clarified yet. This article discusses a conceptual view of the like products definition based on a comprehensive analysis of Boeing-Airbus disputes cases and textual interpretation of SCM Agreement. This article shows that determination of the “likeness” under the SCM Agreement should conform to notes 46 of SCM Agreement. More importantly,“like products” should be assessed from the perspective of “competition relationship of products in the relevant markets”.
-
Key words:
- SCM agreement/
- like product/
- subsidy/
- serious prejudice
-
[1] 单一. WTO框架下补贴与反补贴法律制度与实务[M]. 北京:法律出版社,2009. [2] 马晓平,张曼曼. 国外航空工业补贴对我国补贴大飞机项目的启示[J]. 中国经贸,2008(13):11. [3] 李华. 试论WTO《补贴与反补贴协定》下事实上的出口补贴:以美国诉欧盟及其成员国影响民用大型飞机贸易措施案为例[J]. bob手机在线登陆学报:社会科学版,2010,12(6):92-97. [4] Rambod Behboodi. Industrial subsidies and friction in world trade: trade policy or trade politics[M]. London and New York,1994:30-32. [5] 杨卫东,李寿平. 欧盟及其相关成员国对民用飞机产业的补贴及其启示[J]. bob手机在线登陆学报:社会科学版,2011,13(2):88-93. [6] 张东平. WTO争端解决中的条约解释研究[D]. 厦门:厦门大学,2003:269-274. [7] Won-Mog,Choi. “Like products” in international trade law: towards a consistent GATT/WTO jurisprudence[M]. Oxford University Press,2003:108,110-114. [8] 张淑钿. 论GATT1994第3条国民待遇原则中“同类产品”的认定——以日本酒税案、智利酒税案、韩国酒税案、欧共体石棉案为视角[J]. 时代法学,2006(2):120. [9] 韩宝庆,王向前. 论WTO反倾销领域中“同类产品”的界定方法[J]. 学术交流,2001(5):47-50. [10] 马晓平,江可申,吴秋璟. 大飞机项目补贴障碍分析及策略建议[J]. 对外经贸实务,2009(3):40-42. [11] 史东辉. 大型民用飞机产业的全球市场结构与竞争[M]. 武汉:湖北教育出版社,2008:301-304. [12] Nils Meier-Kaienburg. The WTO’s“toughest” case:an examination of the effectiveness of the WTO dispute resolution procedure in the airbus-boeing dispute over aircraft[J]. Journal of Air Law and Commerce,2007(2):235-243. -
点击查看大图
计量
- 文章访问数:857
- HTML全文浏览量:2
- PDF下载量:125
- 被引次数:0
下载:
