基于行为运作的供应链牛鞭效应研究综述

姓名
邮箱
手机号码
标题
留言内容
验证码

许民利¹,
周依¹

1.
中南大学商学院, 长沙 410083

基金项目:

教育部人文社科基金资助项目(09YJC630230);湖南省自然科学基金资助项目(10JJ3023)

Review of Bullwhip Effect in Supply Chain Based on Behavioral Operations

XU Minli¹,
ZHOU Yi¹

1.
School of Business, Central South University, Changsha 410083, China

摘要:牛鞭效应对供应链效益会造成不良影响。基于完全理性人假设的传统理论,如运作管理、契约理论、博弈论和委托代理理论等,人们对牛鞭效应的成因和解决方案进行了较充分的研究。认为:牛鞭效应的主要成因在于运作管理中的四种主要因素(需求信号处理、限量供应、批量订货方式和价格波动),以及供应链协调、利益分配和供应链结构等方面存在的设计缺陷。但是没有考虑人的行为因素,即人的个体决策偏差和社会偏好也会影响供应链牛鞭效应的形成。个体决策偏差中的过度自信、有限理性以及锚定与调整,会对供应链牛鞭效应的形成产生显著影响。社会偏好中的信任也会对牛鞭效应产生重要影响。最后指出了行为因素对影响牛鞭效应的未来研究方向。
- 行为运作/
- 牛鞭效应/
- 供应链/
- 个体决策偏差
Abstract:The bullwhip effect badly affects the efficiency of supply chain. Based on the rational agent hypothesis, researchers have studied causes and mitigation strategies of the bullwhip effect sufficiently from operation management, contract theory, game theory and principal theory. Demand signal processing, limited supplying, lot-for-lot orders and price volatility are the main factors that cause bullwhip effect. Defects in coordination, distribution of benefits and structure of supply chain also affect bullwhip. Behavioral factors are not included in these theories. Individual decision bias and social preferences can also cause the bullwhip effect. Individual decision bias, including underestimation, overreaction, bounded rationality, anchoring and adjustment, can have impacts on bullwhip significantly. Trust, a kind of social preferences, can also cause bullwhip in supply chain management. At last, future research directions are pointed out.
- behavioral operations/
- bullwhip effect/
- supply chain/
- individual decision bias

[1]	Lee H,Padmanabhan P,Whang S. Information distortion in a supply chain: the bullwhip effect[J]. Management Science,1997,43(4):546-558.
[2]	Forrester. Industrial dynamic[M].New York: MIT Press and Wiley & Sons,Inc,1961.
[3]	Geary S,Disney S M,Towill D R.On bullwhip in supply chains—historical review,present practice and expected future impact[J].International Journal of Production Economics,2006,101(1):2-18.
[4]	达庆利,张钦,沈厚才.供应链中牛鞭效应问题研究[J].管理科学学报,2003,6(3):86-93.
[5]	刘作仪,查勇.行为运作管理: 一个正在显现的研究领域[J].管理科学学报,2009,12(4):64-74.
[6]	Burbidge J L. Automated production control with a simulation capability[R]. IFIP Working Paper,1984.
[7]	Sterman J D. Modeling managerial behavior: misperceptions of feedback in a dynamic decision making experiment[J]. Management Science,1989,35(3):321-339.
[8]	Lee H,Padmanabhan P,Whang S.Information distortion supply chains[J]. Sloan Management Rev,1997,38(3):93-102.
[9]	Cachon G P,Lariviere M A. Capacity allocation using past sales: when to turn-and-earn[J]. Management Science,1999,45(5): 685-703.
[10]	Cachon G P,Lariviere M A. Capacity choice and allocation: strategic behavior and supply chain per formance[J]. Management Science,1999,45(8):1091-1108.
[11]	Kelle P,Milne A. The effect of ordering policy on the supply chain [J]. International Journal of Production Economics,1999,59: 113-122.
[12]	Cachon G P. Managing supply chain demand variability with scheduled ordering policies [J]. Management Science,1999,45(6): 843-856.
[13]	Chen F,Drezner Z,Ryan J,Simchi-Levi D. Quantifying the bullwhip effect in a simple supply chain: the impact of forecasting,lead times,and information[J]. Management Science,2000,46(3):436-443.
[14]	Chen F,Ryan J,Simchi-Levi D. The impact of exponential smoothing forecasts on the bullwhip effect[J]. Naval Research Logistics,2000,47(4):269-286.
[15]	Disney S M,Towill D R. The effect of vendor managed inventory(VMI) dynamics on the bullwhip effect in supply chains[J]. International of Production Economics,2003,85:199-215.
[16]	Kim J G,Chatfield D,Harrison T P,Hayya J C. Quantifying the bullwhip effect in a supply chain with stochastic lead time[J].European Journal of Operational Research,2006,173:617-636.
[17]	Zhang X,Burke G J. Analysis of compound bullwhip effect causes[J].European Journal of Operational Research,2010,210(3): 514-526.
[18]	石小法,张丽清,杨东援.信息对供应链的影响研究[J].系统工程,2002,20(3):37-40.
[19]	张钦,达庆利,沈厚才.在ARIMA(0 ,1 ,1)需求下的牛鞭效应与信息共享的评价[J].中国管理科学,2001,9(6):1-6.
[20]	路应金,唐小我,张勇.供应链中牛鞭效应的分形特征研究[J].系统工程学报,2006,21(5):463-469.
[21]	万杰,李敏强,寇纪淞.供应链中分配机制对牛鞭效应的影响研究[J].系统工程学报,2002,17(4):340-348.
[22]	唐宏祥,何建敏,刘春林.非对称需求信息条件下的供应链信息共享机制[J].系统工程学报,2004,19(6):589-595.
[23]	傅烨,郑绍濂.供应链中的“牛鞭效应”——成因及对策分析[J].管理工程学报,2002,16(1):82-83.
[24]	何红渠,谭丽.供应链管理中的“牛鞭效应”及最优委托权安排[J].中南大学学报:社会科学版,2005,11(5):632-635.
[25]	Gino F,Pisano G.Toward a theory of behavioral operations[J]. Manufacturing Service Operations Management,2008,10(4): 676-691.
[26]	Bendoly E,Donohue K,Schultz K.Behavioral operations management: assessing recent findings and revisiting old assumptions[J].Oper. Management,2006,24(6): 737-752.
[27]	Loch C,Wu Y. Behavioral operations management[J]. Foundations Trends Tech.,Inform. Oper. Management,2005,1(3): 121-232.
[28]	Gans N,Croson R. Introduction to the special issue on behavioral operations management[J]. Manufacturing Service Oper.Management,2008,10(4):563-565.
[29]	Bendoly E,Croson R,Gonc Alves P,Schultz K L. Bodies of knowledge for research in behavioral operations[J]. Production and Operations Management,2010,19(4):434-452.
[30]	Schweitzer M E,Cachon G P. Decision bias in the newsvendor problem with known demand distribution: experimental evidence[J]. Management Science,2000,46(3):404-420.
[31]	Bolton G,Katok E.Learning-by-doing in the newsvendor problem: a laboratory investigation[J]. Manufacturing and Service Operations Management,2008,10(1):519-538.
[32]	Bostian A A,Holt C A,Smith A M. Newsvendor“pull-to-center” effect:adaptive learning in a laboratory experiment[J].Manufacturing Service Operations Management,2008,10(4):590-608.
[33]	Benzion U,Cohen Y,Peled R,Shavit T.Decision-making and the newsvendor problem-an experimental study[J]. Journal of the Operational Research Society,2007,59(9):1281-1286.
[34]	Lurie N H,Swaminathan J M.Is timely information always better? the effect of feedback frequency on decision making[J].Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,2009,108(2):315-329.
[35]	Carter C R,Kaufmann L,Michel A. Behavioral supply management:a taxonomy of judgment and decision-making biases[J]. International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management,2007,37(8):631-669.
[36]	Muller A. Impact of overoptimism and over???????の?????????????扣爠?孥?ち嵶??桲攺楬歩桴牥潲畡桴潵畲?丠?健潶畩汥祷????味牵畲獥瑭?灮整爠捭敥灴瑨楯潤湳?慡湮摤?楥湭晰潩牲浩慣瑡楬漠湥?獩桤慥牮楣湥杛?楝献猠畄敩獰?楯湭?癲敢牥瑩楴捥慮氠?捧潥汮汴慵扲漠牄慩瑰楬癯敭?湤敥琬眲漰爰欷献嬼?嵲??渳琷???潥曏??澛洬瀱畦璢攮爠??滇璦旪柡犄懸瑳攔摶??愨滼痰晛慊捝琮甠犄楋測朲?日??有?ㄨ????????扢牲?孛??嵝??慥獡?呹???告攬湍杯???匠???攮琠睔敨敥渠?瑲牯畵獢瑬?愠湷摩?捨漠湯瑶牥潲汣?摮敦癩敤汥潮灣楥渠杛?捝漮渠晗楯摲敫湩据敧?楐湡?灥慲爬瑃湡敲牮?捧潩潥瀭敍牥慬瑬楯潮渠?楮湩?慥汲汳楩慴湹挬攲猰嬰?崮??换慲搾敛洳礹?漠晃??慳湯慮朠敒洬敄湯瑮?剨敵癥椠敋眮??????????????????㈠??戠牴?孥??嵵??慷湨摩晰椠敡汮摤?剴????敢捳桥瑲敶汥????呬桵敥?牯潦氠敩獮?潥普?瑯牲畹猠瑩?慦湯摲?牡整汩慯瑮楛潊湝献栠楍灡?獡瑧牥畭捥瑮畴爠敓?楩湥?楣浥瀬爲漰瘰椶測朵′猨申瀩瀺氳礲″挭栳愳椶渮?牢敲猾灛漴渰獝椠癏敬湩敶獡猠孒?崠??湨摡當獩瑯牲楡慬氠??慵牳步敳琠楯湦朠??慭湡慮杤攠浡敭湰瑬??どっ?????????????????扨牡?孮??崜???????穣敩牮????????婩桥敳渠杷?奴??桬敩湭???奤?呩牮畦獯瑲?楡湴?景潮爠散捵慥獳瑛?椯湏晌潝爮洠愨琲椰漰渵?猰栶愩牛椲渰朱嬲?崰???愶湝愮朠敨浴整湰琺?匯捷楷敷渮捳敹??づ????????????????????扥牮?孥??崲‰夰攵甯湰杲?????夯?卡数汥敲湳?圠?婌桉慖湁朱″???畤潦???‰吵栺攱?攲昹昮攼换瑲猾?漴昱?琠牎畩獲瑡?慪湡摮?捔漠敔爬捗楡癧敮?灲漠睓攠牍?潂湯?獥甠灃瀮氠楁敮爠?楬湴瑥敲杮牡慴瑩楶潥渠孴?嵥???湴瑩?????偸牰潬摡畮捡瑴楩潯湮??据潤渠潥浭楰捩獲??ちぬ????ど???????????扶牥?孯??嵥??慮执漠汢楥????桯敲椠歩桮爠潳畵桰潰畬?丠??慡物癮楳獛桊????汣慩牳摩潯湮?剓???湮?敥砬瀲攰爱椱洬攴渲琨愴氩?猸琵甹搭礸?漸昮?瑢桲放?爴攲汝愠瑎楩潥湮獨桡極灳?扊攬瑚睩敥敧湥?瑢牥畩獮琠?愬湓摣?楯湥癮敳湬瑥潢牥祮?牐攮瀠汈敯湷椠獨桵浭敡湮琠?楥湨?瑶物楯慵摲椠捡?獰畬灩灥汳礠?捨桥愠楢湵孬?嵷??呰栠敥??瑥档?倬牡漠摳畴捵瑤楹漠湢?慳湥摤?佯灮攠牴慨瑥椠潢湥獥??慤湩慳杴敲浩敢湵瑴?坯潮爠汧摡??漠湯普敬物敮湥捛敊??洠獐瑲敯牤摵慣浴?乯敮琠桐敬牡汮慮湩摮獧??の?㈠????ひ??戬爲?嬰??崱??漶温琺爵攴男椭氵‵???牢潲琾桛攴爳瑝漠湓????氠慈爠摁漮渠?副?敥瑬?愠汯???硡灮敛牍楝攮湎捙攺獊?楨湮?畗獩楬湥杹?塡?敤攠牓?慮浳攬?瘹椵爷琮甼慢汲￣杛愴洴楝渠杓?映潘爮?求敯慵牮湤楥湤朠?獡畴灩灯汮祡?捩桴慹椠湩?洠慮湥慷杳敶浥敮湤瑯孲?嵭???湬摳??畊牝漮瀠敍慡湮??潡湣晴敵牲敩湮捧攠?潥湲??慣浥攠獏??慲獡整摩??敳愠牍湡楮湡杧?卭灥慮楴測?日?????ㄨ???????戵爸?嬮??嵲￣?爴漵獝漠湗?删??潋湡潴桯畫攠????慡瑲潮歩???卣瑯敭牭浵慮湩????佯牮搠敡牮?猠瑴慨扥椠汢極瑬祬?楨湩?猠略灦灦汥祣?捛桊慝椮渠獊?捵潲潮牡摬椠湯慦琠楏潰湥?牡楴獩歯?慳渠摍?瑮桡敧?牭潥汮整?漲昰‰挶漬漲爴搨椶温愺琸椳漹渭?猵琰漮挼止孲刾?伴?嵝????のづ?????嬬?ぬ???っ????嵶????呹?十氮漠慊湵?坧潭牥歮楴渠杵?偤慥灲攠牵?乣潥????????????癩慳楴汩慣扳氠敡?慤琠?桩瑡瑳灥???摝砮?摃潡業?潲物杤?????????獤獧牥渠??ど??????批爠?孲??嵳??愹洸攲爮攼牢???圴攷楝朠敂汬瑯?????硬灤攠牒椠浊攬湇瑩慮汯?瑆攬獋瑵獬?漠晓?慌?猠敂煥畨敡湶瑩楯慲污?攠煣畡極汳楥扳爠楯畦洠?牨敥瀠畢瑵慬瑬楷潨湩?洠潥摦敦汥季?崠???捡漠湳潩浮敧瑬牥椠捥慣??????????????????戭爰?嬭??崩??挰?瘲椭氰礶???呝漮牁瑶潡物楬敡汢汬潥?????敓慒獎町牨楴湴杰?琯爯畳獳瑲?椮湣?潭爯条慢湳楴穲慡瑣楴漽渹愷氷′爰攵献攼慢牲挾桛?爸敝瘠楊敯睨?慳湯摮?片敥捯潲浧浥攠湃搬慓瑷楡潰渠獗嬠?崮???潡畳牵湲慥汭?潮晴?呯牦甠獳瑰?牣敩獦敩慣爠捩桮??ひ????????㈠??????扣牯?孳?ひ嵵??慩湯瑮漠牡????慡捬摩潤湡慴汩摯???剦???敳捣楡獬楥漠湴?洠慡歳楳湥杳?椠湴?瑵桳整?獩畮瀠灡氠祳?捥档慩楦湩?琠桯整?楥浲灛慍捝琮?潊昮?捐潥杲湳楯瑮楡癬敩?瑹栠楓湯正椮湐杳?獣瑨礮氱改猸′愬渴搳?瀶爩漺戱氳攰洶?挱漳洱瀷氮攼硢楲琾祛嬴?嵝???潹略牲渠慒氠?漬晄?佶灩敳爠慊琠楈漬湓獣??慯湲慭条敮洠敆渠瑄?㈠ぁの??????????ぶ?㈠????扬爠?学??嵲??慮湩瑺潡牴????慬琠潴歲????偊牝漮搠畁捣瑡楤潥湭?猠浯潦漠瑍桡楮湡杧?業湥?慴?獒敥牶楩慥汷?猀甀瀀瀀氀礀?挀栀愀椀渀?愀?氀愀戀漀爀愀琀漀爀礀?椀渀瘀攀猀琀椀最愀琀椀漀渀嬀?崀??吀爀愀渀猀瀀漀爀琀愀琀椀漀渀?刀攀猀攀愀爀挀栀?倀愀爀琀????　???????????????戀爀?嬀??崀??愀欀愀樀椀???????一椀欀漀氀椀?????????倀愀渀椀?????????椀爀欀漀?嘀甀樀漀??????攀瘀椀???????????甀氀氀眀栀椀瀀?攀昀昀攀挀琀?愀渀搀?猀甀瀀瀀氀礀?挀栀愀椀渀?洀漀搀攀氀椀渀最?愀渀搀?愀渀愀氀礀猀椀猀?甀猀椀渀最??倀一?琀漀漀氀猀嬀?崀??倀爀漀挀攀攀搀椀渀最?漀昀?琀栀攀??琀栀?圀漀爀欀猀栀漀瀀?愀渀搀?吀甀琀漀爀椀愀氀?漀渀?倀爀愀挀琀椀挀愀氀?唀猀攀?漀昀??漀氀漀甀爀攀搀?倀攀琀爀椀?一攀琀猀?愀渀搀?琀栀攀??倀一?吀漀漀氀猀??愀爀栀甀猀??攀渀洀愀爀欀??　　??????????

[1]	胡俊, 吴君民, 吴洁, 盛永祥, 施琴芬.创新驱动下光伏产业供应链的竞争与协调研究_^*——基于政府竞争政策. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2021, (): -.
[2]	桑圣举, 张强.考虑企业社会责任的绿色供应链优化决策. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2020, 22(2): 107-116.doi:10.15918/j.jbitss1009-3370.2020.6877
[3]	王哲, 李帮义, 刘志, 王玥, 陈玉玉.双责任闭环供应链的生产决策和责任分担机制. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2018, (4): 109-119.doi:10.15918/j.jbitss1009-3370.2018.1470
[4]	浦徐进, 赵媛媛, 李栋栋.基于二层供应链捆绑销售策略及垂直合作广告机制. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2016, (5): 83-90.doi:10.15918/j.jbitss1009-3370.2016.0511
[5]	冉伦, 武丹, 雷俊丽.框架效应影响下的航空收益管理决策偏差. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2015, (1): 83-88.doi:10.15918/j.jbitss1009-3370.2015.0112
[6]	李星北, 齐二石.供应链企业创新的风险偏好信息价值分析. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2015, (4): 80-86.doi:10.15918/j.jbitss1009-3370.2015.0411
[7]	周海云, 杜纲, 安彤.回收条例约束下双渠道营销闭环供应链的决策与协调. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2014, (5): 65-70,76.
[8]	丁志刚, 徐琪.供应链实施低碳技术的博弈与激励机制研究. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2014, (4): 13-17.
[9]	陈正杨.社会救援资源应急供应链的协同管理. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2013, (3): 95-99.
[10]	鹿红娟, 邵宏宇, 郭伟.发动机再制造的闭环供应链回收决策研究. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2013, (3): 84-88.
[11]	曹国昭, 齐二石.新产品市场中创业型企业品种柔性技术决策. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2013, (5): 74-80.
[12]	韩敬稳, 赵道致.力量不对等供应链下游寡头行为演化机理. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2012, (2): 51-57.
[13]	吕君.供应链任务分配和决策机制研究. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2011, (5): 34-38,43.
[14]	赵涛, 李小鹏.绿色供应链管理绩效评价研究. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2010, (5): 80-83.
[15]	钟敏, 马可, 杨华.延期支付条件下的供应链信用风险声誉激励机制. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2009, (4): 33-35.
[16]	齐二石, 崔铭伟, 宋立夫.基于供应链管理的制造业信息化评价模型研究. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2008, (6): 36-40.
[17]	封云, 马军海.供应链需求预测的非线性方法研究. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2008, (5): 82-86.
[18]	赵涛, 吴文东.供应链知识节点作用机制研究. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2006, (4): 60-62.
[19]	盛望京, 吴祈宗.敏捷供应链协作伙伴关系建立过程研究. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2005, (5): 57-59.
[20]	郭文才, 刘金兰.基于多代理和XML的供应链集成体系结构研究. bob手机在线登陆学报（社会科学版）, 2005, (3): 69-72.

点击查看大图

计量

文章访问数:970
HTML全文浏览量:1
PDF下载量:1465
被引次数:0

留言板

基于行为运作的供应链牛鞭效应研究综述

Review of Bullwhip Effect in Supply Chain Based on Behavioral Operations

计量

基于行为运作的供应链牛鞭效应研究综述

1. 中南大学商学院, 长沙 410083

English Abstract

Review of Bullwhip Effect in Supply Chain Based on Behavioral Operations

1. School of Business, Central South University, Changsha 410083, China

目录

作者相关

写作规范

友情链接

留言板

基于行为运作的供应链牛鞭效应研究综述

Review of Bullwhip Effect in Supply Chain Based on Behavioral Operations

计量

出版历程

基于行为运作的供应链牛鞭效应研究综述

1. 中南大学 商学院, 长沙 410083

English Abstract

Review of Bullwhip Effect in Supply Chain Based on Behavioral Operations

1. School of Business, Central South University, Changsha 410083, China

目录

作者相关

写作规范

友情链接

1. 中南大学商学院, 长沙 410083